[Photo: Gary Lisbon]
A cloud is hanging over the immediate future of Monash Country Club, No.90 in the 2026-2027 Australian Golf Digest ranking of the Top 100 Golf Courses in Australia.
Monash Holdings Limited, an unlisted public company with about 1,000 shareholders who are mostly descendants of Monash Country Club’s Jewish founders, owns the 65-hectares on which the golf club operates at Ingleside on Sydney’s northern beaches.
RELATED: The National Golf Club revolt erupts into defamation dispute
In September it issued four formal notices that Monash Country Club had breached conditions of its lease and, consequentially, has refused to grant a 20-year extension option in the current lease. The club has responded by seeking ratification of its lease extension by the NSW Supreme Court. A date has not been set for a ruling.
Meanwhile, with only six weeks until the lease expires, the 1,200 Monash members who pay up to $6,000 a year plus competition fees are in limbo about their playing futures. Members who joined in the past four years have paid entrance fees of up to $15,000 which will be forfeited if the club can’t operate beyond December.
Monash was launched in 1950 by Jewish players who could not belong to or play in competitions at established Sydney clubs. They were denied entry to prestigious clubs like Royal Sydney (from 1908), but in the early 1930s were welcomed at others, starting with now-defunct Ashlar at Blacktown (now Stonecutters Ridge), followed by Moore Park and Bonnie Doon. They played under the moniker of ‘Y’ golfers, an abbreviation for the Young Men’s Hebrew Association, formed in 1929.
Literally hacked out of the bush by founding members after the first parcel of the property was bought in 1947, Monash has become one of Sydney’s leading golf clubs, notably adopting a non-discriminatory membership policy since inception.
Its fast bentgrass greens and kikuyu fairways in a parkland setting are complemented by usually impeccable conditioning and wonderful Pacific Ocean views.
The course hosted the 1984 Australian PGA Championship won by Greg Norman, has produced several amateur champions and Asian Tour players and is the home club of current PGA Tour player Cameron Davis.
RELATED: Course Review – Monash Country Club
Named after Sir John Monash, the acclaimed World War I general of Jewish descent, Monash compares favourably with its prestigious near-neighbour, Elanora Country Club and, about 10 kilometres away, Terrey Hills Golf & Country Club.
Currently zoned RU2 Rural Landscape, the property could be worth more than $100 million if it was able to be developed for commercial residential use. It is now able to be used only for agriculture, agri-tourism, animal nurseries and low-impact rural or leisure activities, but can not support commercial residential dwellings.
The move by Monash Holdings to terminate the golf club’s lease partly reflects a lack of involvement by many current shareholders with the club. Whereas founding members played and supported the golf course from the outset, their descendants don’t have the same level of affinity or involvement.
Directors of Monash Holdings include property developer Kate Melocik, the managing director of David Landa Stewart Lawyers, Simon Singer, a son of former Westfield owner Frank Lowy, Steven Lowy, and executive director of Macquarie Capital, Antony Green.
RELATED: Travel – Harbour city havens
It is understood the current lease required a majority of Monash Holdings members to sit on the Monash Country Club board. This was relaxed about five years ago, supposedly by mutual agreement. But documented evidence of the agreement is said to be missing and is apparently one of the lease breaches alleged by the landowner. The golf club quickly changed its board composition after the breaches were notified and now comprises four (Jewish) Monash Holdings directors and three others who were on the previous board, including president Jeff Bresnahan.
Monash Country Club reported cashflow from members of $7.7 million and net profit of $148,112 in 2024-2025. Monash Holdings reported lease income of $106,000 and receipts from Monash Country Club of $125,000 in the same year. Its annual report valued the land and development at just $3.9 million.
There is currently one residential dwelling on the course, occupied by the course superintendent.


