[Photo: Gary Lisbon]

A bitter battle over the future of one of Australia’s most prestigious golf clubs has escalated into a legal dispute, with former captain of The National Golf Club, Bill Stevens, accusing the club’s leadership of making false and damaging claims about his conduct.

A membership revolt at the club on Victoria’s Mornington Peninsula has taken a dramatic turn, with Stevens issuing a formal defamation “concerns notice” to club chair Patricia Cross-Meadows and current captain Andrew Tunks.

RELATED: Why good golf club governance means playing the long game

The legal action follows an increasingly bitter dispute over the club’s financial position and a proposal to issue up to 300 new shares or memberships.

Stevens, through law firm Hall & Wilcox, claims communications sent to The National’s more than 3,000 members portrayed him as having knowingly misled shareholders during his campaign against the proposal.

“The imputations… are serious and false,” the concerns notice states, according to Code Sports.

The notice alleges the publications have caused “serious harm” to Stevens’ reputation and claims he has subsequently been shunned by fellow members when attending the club.

At the heart of the dispute is The National’s plan to raise funds as it confronts increasing capital costs across its Cape Schanck and Frankston facilities. Stevens became the prominent figurehead of a group opposing the proposal, arguing the resolution would give the club an unconditional right to issue all 300 memberships rather than limiting new memberships to 30 each year.

The club rejected that interpretation, telling members it “unconditionally” disagreed with Stevens’ assessment and maintained that an annual cap of 30 new memberships applied.

The National subsequently circulated communications to its approximately 3,200 members criticising Stevens’ campaign.

According to the concerns notice, one letter described his conduct as “unacceptable” and bordering on “conduct unbecoming of a member of our great club”.

The dispute has also raised questions over the authorship of a letter urging members to reject Stevens’ “No” campaign. The letter was attributed to former chairman and captain Peter Jonson, but metadata analysis reportedly indicated it had been authored by a club official.

The National’s chief executive, Matt Corby, rejected suggestions Jonson was not the author, telling the Herald Sun that Jonson had prepared the letter and sent a draft to the club for factual verification before it was distributed.

“The author of the letter was Mr Jonson,” Corby said. “Mr Jonson sent a draft of the letter to the club for factual verification before it was sent to shareholders.”

The legal dispute comes as the underlying financial disagreement remains unresolved.

Stevens’ supporters argue The National’s financial challenges stem partly from its 2015 merger with Long Island Country Club and believe selling the Long Island property could help secure the long-term future of the club’s three-course Cape Schanck operation.

What began as a debate over membership numbers and The National’s financial strategy has now become a significant test of governance, reputation and unity at one of Australian golf’s most prominent clubs.