It was an incredible finish at Colonial, unless you were the journeyman whose dream win just got whacked

By

To make $10 million on the PGA Tour without winning an event means you’ve had a nice career, but it’s even nicer to make that list and come off it.

For large stretches on Sunday at the Charles Schwab Challenge, Eric Cole looked like he was on the verge of living the triumphant second half of that trajectory. The 37-year-old PGA Tour journeyman came into the week with $12.4 million to his name on tour in 120 starts, but also zero victories. His final round at historic Colonial Country Club in Fort Worth wasn’t spectacular, but it was solid, and he would end up with an even-par 70 following the Saturday 63 that gave him the 54-hole lead. When he found the 18th fairway with a dead-straight 301-yard drive, he marched to his ball and had a view of the last obstacle to his victory, Russell Henley, ahead on the green, standing over a difficult 16-foot birdie putt. Cole just needed Henley to miss.

Related: The clubs Russell Henley used to win the 2026 Charles Schwab Challenge

The universe didn’t need to give us another example of golf’s cruelty, but at least from Cole’s perspective, it did just that. Henley drilled the putt, let out an uncharacteristic scream, and pumped his fist. He had made birdie on the last three holes to reach 12 under and re-insert himself into a final-round narrative that had left him behind. He also sent clubhouse leader and defending champion Ben Griffin packing at 11 under, another victory for the ghost of Ben Hogan, who remains the only man to win this tournament back-to-back.

Of course, Cole still had his chances. He could make birdie from 137 yards out in regulation, for one. But when his approach trickled into the left rough, and his excellent chip ran left of the hole, it was on to a playoff.

Russell Henley, ahead on the green, standing over a difficult 16-foot birdie putt. Cole just needed Henley to miss.

2279124762

[Photo: Stacy Revere]

Four straight birdies to close the tournament gave Russell Henley a sixth career PGA Tour title.

It felt like fate had made up its mind to deny him again, but then the script flipped, briefly, when Cole’s drive on 18 in the playoff soared straight into the branches of the trees lining the left side of the fairway. Somehow, the ball escaped the leaves with minimal interference, landed in the rough, and kicked out into the short grass, where it still had enough momentum to roll 327 yards, well past Henley’s well-executed 307-yard drive on the right side.

“That looked grim, and somehow it comes out,” Jim Nantz said on the CBS broadcast, his voice hitting a new, hopeful register.

But that’s where hope tipped its cap and bolted. Henley, now somewhere beyond scorching, had a long conversation with his caddie, Andy Sanders, then hit his approach to four feet. Cole couldn’t do better than 12 feet, and when he played too much break on the birdie putt, the end was nigh.

Henley drove in the stake. He celebrated his sixth PGA Tour win with his artist wife and trio of children, and deserved every smile after his closing three-under 67. Like PGA Championship winner Aaron Rai at Aronimink, Henley seized a tournament where the main combatants had been stuck in neutral, and his four birdies in four holes are one of the great closing stretches we’ll see this year.

“I was feeling jittery or quick on the front,” he said, “and it was frustrating to turn at one over, but Andy just said, ‘let’s reset.’ I calmed down a little, hit some good shots, and I felt like I was hitting good putts all day. … They just went in at the end.

“I just kept telling myself I want to win, I want to be here, I want to be hitting these putts and in contention. … I’m still shaken. That was the most nervous I’ve been over a putt in my life.”

Henley admitted that he’s felt mentally “off” this year, and the last time he was in the public eye to this degree, he was looking uncertain and maybe a little miserable at the Bethpage Ryder Cup last fall, where he went 0-2 against Scottie Scheffler and then had to watch his singles opponent Shane Lowry bury the Cup-winning putt. Henley spoke of a reset after the turn, but this is a large-scale reset that re-establishes the momentum of the late-career resurgence that propelled the 37-year-old Georgia native into the top 10 in the world.

But what’s good for Henley is bad for Cole, and it was impossible not to feel for the Palm Springs native. Cole comes from a strong lineage of professional golfers; his father, Bobby Cole, won on the PGA Tour, and his mother, Laura Baugh, finished runner-up 10 times on the professional tour. Oh, and Sunday happened to be his mother’s 71st birthday. It would have been perfect in a few ways, but instead, he could only utter a simple, poignant line to the CBS cameras:

“I just needed to shoot one shot better.”

Cole was proud of himself for hanging tough after a few hiccups, including a double bogey on the ninth, and he’ll reap some rewards beyond the money, including a spot in next week’s signature event at The Memorial. But his body language told the truth; disappointment was paramount. Out here, you just don’t get very many chances to win.