PGA Championship 2025: ‘Don’t do it’: Justin Thomas immediately proves announcer wrong with preposterous recovery shot

By

Curtis Strange made one last impassioned plea. Well, two, technically.

“Don’t do it,” Strange said while watching Justin Thomas debate whether or not to play his third shot at Quail Hollow’s 18th hole on Thursday. “Don’t do it.”

“It” was what looked to be not just an impossible chip shot from the rough left of the green, but a shot that, if Thomas actually attempted, could effectively end his week. The two-time PGA champion had gotten off to a rough start on Thursday, going out in 39, and had worked so hard to climb all the way back to one over. Why, now, would he even consider undoing all that good work with a potentially boneheaded decision to play this hero shot?

In fairness to Strange, a two-time U.S. Open winner serving as an analyst for ESPN this week, Thomas’ decision to ultimately give this a go was playing with serious fire. His wedge could have easily hit that rock on the downswing and caused a whiff, which would have been a stroke. And even if he did somehow miss it, there was a strong chance it wouldn’t even clear the water. 

What Strange, and perhaps everyone else watching with baited breath, forgot was that Thomas is arguably the most creative player in the sport when it comes to shots like this one. He’s practiced and executed on them all. Once he took off his left shoe and sock, we should have known something special was coming:

“That’s incredible,” Van Pelt said. 

“No, it’s better than that,” Strange replied.

Perfectly said. Thomas’ third rolled out to 12 feet, setting up a solid look at par that he’d ultimately go on to miss. But the decision ended up being worth it as Thomas’ bogey gave him a two-over 73, which may read “T-77” on the leader board but is by no means out of the tournament, especially considering his history in this specific one. A drop there more than likely leads to a double bogey six or worse, which would have placed him outside the top 100. A smart, calculated risk by JT. 

MORE GOLF DIGEST PGA CHAMPIONSHIP COVERAGE 

PGA Championship 101: Answering all your frequently asked questions  

How to watch the 2025 PGA Championship

Power Rankings: Every player in the PGA field, ranked  

The 13 best bets to win at Quail Hollow

Tee times for the first and second round 

Crunching the numbers: Why Rory McIlroy is so good at Quail Hollow

Quail Hollow’s three-hole stretch that could decide the PGA Championship 

PGA Championship: Better in May or August?

Where have all the Cinderella major champions gone? 

The things that still shock us from Scottie Scheffler’s bizarre arrest at the 2024 PGA

The most ‘PGA’ moments in PGA Championship history 

This article was originally published on golfdigest.com