ST. SIMON’S ISLAND, Ga. — In every failed golf round, there’s a moment where impossibility engulfs the last flickers of hope. For Billy Horschel at the RSM Classic, it came on the 17th hole on Friday, when a 10-foot par putt refused to fall, and he found himself two strokes off the cut line with one hole to play—a par 4, unfortunately.

Two holes earlier, a testy two-putt for birdie got him to one under, a score that would have seen him through to the weekend if he could just play the closing stretch at even par. The residue of a difficult season still weighed on his mind, though, and the weather was doing him no favors either, with a steady drizzle increasing to a driving rain as the gray afternoon grew darker, and wind gusts whipping the Spanish moss that hung from the branches of the oaks, junipers, and palms rising beside the swamps.

(Horschel, by the way, was the only person I saw among players, caddies, media, or fans who wore short sleeves to the bitter end.)

That wind held up two straight approaches, depositing his ball in two straight bunkers, and leading to two straight bogeys. Coming up 18, Horschel’s only chance was to hole out for eagle, but instead he found a third bunker and then swipe-missed a meaningless 21-inch bogey putt in frustration. He shot three-over 74 on the day and ended up missing the cut by five shots.

Horschel came into the week ranked 101st in the FedEx Cup standings, which was in some ways quite a feat considering the hip surgery that took away most of his 2025 season. The process of strengthening the muscles and learning to trust his new level of mobility had led to his most disappointing season in years.

Not since 2012 had he finished worse than the top 100, and he came into the barrier islands this week with a good chance to keep that streak alive. But there’s no way to improve if you don’t make a cut, and everything depended on Horschel shooting even par Friday. Two front-nine bogeys made that task harder than it first seemed, and the valiant fight back, culminating in his birdie at 15, couldn’t last for the man who played 31 events this year, the second-most on tour.

In August, after failing to make the playoffs at the Wyndham, Horschel rated his season an “F,” and when I asked him on Friday if that had changed at all in the fall, when he made four cuts and had two top-25 finishes, he gave himself only a little grace.

“Maybe F-plus,” he said.

Horschel seemed to be in good spirits and typically voluble in his post-round remarks (in a situation where many players would have been frosty or outright refused to speak). He elaborated on the hip troubles that sabotaged the first three months of his career, how his putting let him down when the hip started feeling better around April, and how once the putting improved in August, the ball-striking became faulty…in part because his hip occasionally gives out on the backswing. Still, despite the strengthening work he needs to do in the short offseason, he said he wished the 2027 season would start tomorrow.

Part of Horschel’s optimism can be explained by the nuances of “missing his card.” While that language may sound like to lose a card means vanishing into a professional void, the practical reality is far rosier. He’ll retain conditional status by finishing in the top 110 (his current projection is to be 105th), and while he’ll miss signature events, he knows he’ll have no problem getting in 20 tournaments and has even started planning his phone call to the people at the WM Phoenix Open who hand out sponsor’s exemptions.

“I’ve got to be able to take advantage of those opportunities like a Ben Kohles did, a Jackson Suber, a Doug Ghim,” Horschel said, citing the players who have earned top status despite not qualifying for signature events at the start of the season. “Those three guys right there are great people to copy for next year.”

But he knows there’s plenty of work to get back to where he believes he should be. He said he wasn’t nervous on Friday with his tour card on the line, but he admitted that the year has been more mentally challenging than most.

“I’ve dealt with more anxiety than I’ve ever had in my career, dealt with more nerves than I ever had in my career,” he said. “I think that comes from a little bit of the known, just not confident enough in my game.”

Horschel leaves Sea Island, and the 2026 season, with wounded pride and an uncertain future, but one look at him standing at the flash area, still drenched after another disappointing round, would cure you of the idea that his spirit has flagged in any way.

“I still believe there’s a major in my future,” he said. “I just have to work hard, I have to work on the right things … we have two-plus months to get better, and I’m excited to get to work tomorrow.”

This article was originally published on golfdigest.com