“Are we going to ride or walk today?” It’s a question golfers constantly ask before teeing off to different results. But one former tour pro with very strong feelings on the subject doesn’t think it should be a question at all.
RELATED: Which way of playing golf leads to your best scores?
Mike Clayton is a winner on the European and Australasia Tours. He’s a golf course architect. And in recent years, he’s become one of the most-respected voices on Golf Twitter. He also just reignited an age-old debate with this tweet.
One of golf’s great crimes. An easily walkable course + four under 25yo in carts. Makes me want to throw up pic.twitter.com/Sx76306iNi
— Mike Clayton (@mikeclaytongolf) September 29, 2024
Of course, Mike is entitled to his opinion. (Even if this one involving tne thought of him potentially vomitting seems a bit harsh.) And he makes some great points.
First, walking is unquestionably better for people than riding. And, showing his position as a golf architect, walking is also unquestionably better for golf courses. But many took exception to his take.
I’m very pro-walking on the golf course.
But…when I started golfing I was a laborer. I worked hard labor 60 hours a week on my feet.
I may have never picked up golf without carts. Golf was a restful activity for us labor folk.
Is that really worth vomiting for? https://t.co/0KTZwsOT1S
— Rick Golfs (@Top100Rick) September 29, 2024
I’m perfectly fine with this picture. I’m way less fine with the amount of gatekeeping that goes on in golf.
What if we just let people enjoy the game the way they want to? If they aren’t hurting the course or slowing up play, I don’t care how they play. You shouldn’t either. https://t.co/yqGzJYrg5R
— Jonathan Shuskey (@j_shuskey1) October 1, 2024
I ain't carrying my golf bag and a cooler with all my beers, pal. Kick rocks. https://t.co/T9W7IIk7U3
— Kev (@KbecKev) September 30, 2024
Tone deaf Tweet by someone who has only played golf or been around golf for their career. Work a real job and get back to me. https://t.co/vRFtXtzMrc
— Blanket Dog (@theblanketdog) September 30, 2024
How about we just let people play golf however they want to play?
As long as they are respectful to the staff, other players and the course, why should you care if they choose to ride?
The post below is exactly what golf needs less of.
— Lou Stagner (Golf Stat Pro) (@LouStagner) October 1, 2024
As you can see, many of those dissenters think that we shouldn’t criticize golfers for how they want to enjoy the game. You know, the old GROW THE GAME argument. And there’s certainly merit to that as well.
As some pointed out, there are also plenty of courses that require carts due to their design or trying to raise revenue. Although in this case, Clayton was talking about a specific course that wasn’t difficult to walk and didn’t make golfers take a cart.
There were also plenty of people who sided with Clayton and thought these young men should tough it out and use their legs.
Totally agree. Huge fan of walking a golf course. https://t.co/Cwpgemmy7L
— Nicholas Huba (@ACPressHuba) September 29, 2024
What’s also crazy is if you’re playing a $40 course walking, the $15-25 cart fee puts a ~50% premium on the round. Annualized it’s a new set of clubs you’re losing just to be lazy and you’re also in worse shape https://t.co/QTM2ncuHVi
— btuck (@BrandonTucker) September 29, 2024
It's ridiculous how few people walk nowadays. There's a nice executive course near me. 14 par 3s & 4 short par 4s. Easiest walk ever and I'd say 9/10 people ride. https://t.co/J7DwPRhhB7
— Matthew Westhoff (@mjwesthoff) September 29, 2024
Although, even Clayton conceded one situation where walking would be acceptable:
Fair enough in Texas summers. Ugh.
— Mike Clayton (@mikeclaytongolf) September 29, 2024
In any event, we can see both sides of the argument. We also don’t want to keep anyhone from playing this great game that we love. In other words, “Walk or ride?” is a question that isn’t going away anytime soon.
RELATED: Seemingly innocuous photo leads to harsh blowback from Golf Twitter
This article was originally published on golfdigest.com