Given how absolutely buckled Salim “The Dream” was during the Internet Invitational finale, it’s hard to imagine a scenario where the Red Team is even able to push that match to the 18th hole, let alone win it. The guy was so beyond gone that Dave Portnoy, who is hardly straight edge, had to get him a designated golf cart driver. For liability reasons. Thankfully, it seems like this experience was a wake-up call for Salim, who has just completed a 90-day sober challenge. We wish him well.
Unfortunately, though, his antics at Big Cedar Lodge cost himself, former NHLer Ryan Whitney and rising internet star Big John a chance at $1.3 million, each. That said, even in his drunken state, there was a path to victory, or at least to a much closer match that would have created the pressurized environment coming down the stretch that Portnoy desperately craved. And no, it wasn’t just about taking the driver out of his hands.
Of course, that would have helped their chances immensely, especially after seeing that Salim could rip an iron down the middle later in the match. But it could have also helped their chances for Salim to not drink at all, or to force feed him a cheeseburger and french fries after the morning nine holes. I’m not here to debate all that, I’m here because I’m still hyper-focused on a crucial moment where the whole thing could have flipped in the Red Team’s favor – the par-5 eighth hole.
RELATED: Internet Invitational participant calls out Barstool’s ‘podcast muppets’
Somehow, some way, despite Salim already depositing two balls into the shadow realm, the Red Team was only 1 down on the eighth tee. Bobby Ray of the Blue Team even remarked on how embarrassing it was that they weren’t running away with it, and he was correct. Then, at the eighth, the Red Team had a prime opportunity to further the embarrassment went, after Riggs hit the fairway but was well back of Whitney’s drive, Bobby Ray chunked a 5 iron into a bunker near the green, leaving Fat Perez with a tricky long sand shot.
This was also the same point where “Cheddy” had accidentally yelled to pump up Salim while Bobby Ray was standing over his shot, causing quite the reaction from Riggs, who must have been feeling the heat. After cooler heads prevailed, Ray hit and it was Red’s/Salim’s turn. This is where the whole thing crumbled:
Now, as Whitney has already mentioned on multiple different Barstool podcasts, he felt there wasn’t much he and Big John could do to reel the overserved Salim in. But I feel this particular moment was a grave strategical error that ultimately did them in. Reminder: they are only 1 down at this point. A win on this hole flips the entire match. A tie keeps the pressure on.
Apparently, Whitney thought that the best path there was for Salim, who had been hitting a nervy, armsy pull-hook the entire day up to that point, was to hit a pinpoint 150-yard shot to the left side of the fairway with trouble left of said fairway from a hook lie. That Salim muttered under his breath “I can get us farther” was irrelevant. This plan was doomed from the start.
Whitney’s logic, of course, was fair. Get it to here, and Big John has a perfect angle into a tricky front right pin that he can carve a fade into. At this point, Whitney is probably thinking they need birdies to win. But in match play, when you’re only 1 down, you need to take into account that the Blue team has a very difficult bunker shot coming up, and that a par should be good enough to tie, at worst. You simply cannot make a bogey and lose this hole and go 2 down. Assuming these teams are even (they are not with Salim, but let’s just assume), your win probability when 2 down after 8 holes is somewhere in the 30-35 percent range. If you then push the ninth and go 2 down at the turn, it goes down to 15-20 percent. The Red Team wound up going 3 down after 9 when Salim hit another ball off the planet, decreasing their chances to win to roughly eight percent.
That’s why this particular moment was so crucial. You obviously don’t want to play for ties, but you sort of have to when the match is still close like this and you have a liability like Salim on your team. So what were there other options?
For starters, let’s take a look at this screenshot:
Man, seems like there’s some room to the right there! Or, a place to aim for a guy hitting a nasty pull hook. And, listen, as someone who is prone to the nasty pull hook, there’s sometimes no amount of aiming right you can do to corral it. In fact, some would argue the further right you aim the worse it hooks. But you have to try anything at this point with Salim. Option 1 would have been to literally have him aim right of the ninth tee box and if he hits it dead straight into the woods, God Bless him. You were never winning anyway. If he hits a nasty pull hook, it might end up somewhere in the vicinity of the Blue Team’s third, or somewhere short of it.
RELATED: Kevin Kisner casually dropped two great tips during the Internet Invitational finale
The other option would have been to be as safe as humanly possible, which, again, is easier said from the couch. Put a 60-degree wedge in his hands. A pitching wedge if that makes him feel better. Hey, Salim, just bunt this one out to the fairway. We don’t care if it goes 50 yards or 120. But it has to be advanced forward and it HAS to be in the fairway. Without distance, it’s hard to know how long Big John would have left, but he’s clearly a good enough player to handle something in the 180-220-yard range. He’d be able to get the next one on the green and get a look at birdie, which would have ensured them a tie, at minimum. Instead, Salim hit it out, Big John took “the worst drop of all time,” and they lost the hole outright. Everything fell apart from there.
Even if they win this hole, do they pull off the miracle and win the match? Probably not, especially with Salim teeing off on the next hole. But momentum is a real thing in match play. A win or tie there keeps the pressure on, and maybe they can convince Salim earlier to stop hitting driver in a closer, tenser match. But the moment Whitney went to the left side of the fairway and asked the pull-hooker to hit it to him with death lurking left of him, that was all she wrote.
This article was originally published on golfdigest.com

